Why David Eby failed – the economic case against government overreach

David Eby
David Eby, who was the leader of the BC NDP. Photo courtesy of BC NDP, CCSA 2.0

By Romel Dhalla

David Eby’s economic record raises a question: did his government strengthen the productive economy sufficiently to sustain its public commitments? From a capitalist perspective, the criticism of the NDP’s socialist policy tradition concerns its reliance on taxation, intervention and government direction, alongside persistent barriers facing private investment.

The NDP inherited an economy heavily exposed to property when it returned to government in 2017. Eby became premier in 2022. Neither invented that dependence. Their responsibility was to reduce it by strengthening other industries. After years in office, blaming predecessors could no longer substitute for building a more resilient economy.

Federal labour-market analysis places finance, insurance, real estate, rental and leasing at 24.3 per cent of provincial GDP in 2024. That broad category includes useful services and housing consumption; it is not simply speculative buying. Nevertheless, it illustrates how deeply property and finance are embedded in British Columbia’s economic structure.

Real estate does not always go up. When interest rates rise, mortgage affordability deteriorates, developers face higher financing costs, buyers retreat and projects become harder to finance. Construction slows, transactions weaken and property-related tax revenues suffer. An economy excessively dependent on this cycle discovers that rising asset values were never a substitute for productivity.

The Bank of Canada documented average variable mortgage rates rising from 1.5 to 5.9 per cent between January 2022 and January 2023. Provincial governments do not control monetary policy. They do control whether their economies have enough productive alternatives when expensive credit exposes the weaknesses of property-led growth.

Eby’s housing platform illustrated his preference for further intervention when markets disappointed. His 2026 campaign proposed taxing completed condominiums left empty for more than a year, beginning at two per cent and increasing thereafter. The stated objective was to force homes onto the market at affordable prices.

But an unsold condominium is not automatically evidence of a developer withholding supply. It can reflect buyers unable to qualify, financing constraints or construction costs exceeding achievable prices. Adding carrying costs may accelerate some sales. It can also weaken lenders’ confidence and discourage the next development. The proposal required closer scrutiny of those risks.

Forestry illustrates the importance of maintaining productive capacity. The British Columbia Chamber of Commerce reports that softwood lumber production has fallen roughly 60 per cent since 2016. Its assessment identifies unpredictable access to timber, duplicative permitting and high costs as serious obstacles. Communities cannot sustain mills on ministerial assurances when usable fibre remains inaccessible.

The warnings were explicit. In May 2024, announcing a Northwood production-line curtailment affecting approximately 220 jobs, Canfor Pulp said harvest levels were below allowable cuts partly because of natural disturbances, but increasingly because of policy choices and regulatory complexity. That was an employer identifying operational barriers, not an abstract ideological disagreement.

Wildfires, beetle damage, American duties and global prices also matter.

Those factors prevent a simple attribution of every closure to provincial policy. The market-oriented criticism is that regulatory costs and uncertain timber access added pressures that government had greater capacity to address.

Mining presents a similar test. British Columbia possesses minerals the world needs, but geological potential does not guarantee investment. In March 2026, the Association for Mineral Exploration reported median mineral-claim decision times of 143 days, exceeding the government’s 90–120-day standard. Delays at the earliest stage can cost explorers an entire field season.

The framework implements a constitutional duty to consult; its delays should be distinguished from DRIPA itself. The relevant criticism is whether government supplied adequate capacity and predictable administration while meeting that duty and maintaining long-term investor confidence.
There were achievements: the province reported record exploration spending of $751 million in 2025 and measures to accelerate permitting.

Those successes deserve recognition. They also demonstrate the opportunity cost of administrative failure. A promising industry should not have to succeed around government bottlenecks.
DRIPA intensified the debate about certainty.

Enacted in 2019, the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act requires provincial laws to be made consistent with the United Nations declaration. Reconciliation is a legitimate obligation. Government remains responsible for explaining how its legislation changes decisions, responsibilities and investment risk.

The legal consequences became more substantial when the Court of Appeal ruled in December 2025 that DRIPA incorporated the declaration into provincial law and created enforceable rights. The Supreme Court of Canada subsequently granted leave to appeal. Businesses were therefore navigating an evolving framework whose ultimate interpretation remained unsettled.

The reported economic harm warrants attention. In a 2026 Business Council of British Columbia member survey, 74 per cent of respondents identified decreased investment plans among DRIPA’s effects; 73 per cent reported greater permitting time, cost, complexity or uncertainty. Forty-one per cent reported harder access to external financing.

These were 88 responses from a business membership survey; they do not establish the size of any province-wide investment loss caused by DRIPA. They nevertheless describe a serious confidence problem. Capital committees price uncertainty. When decision authority, timelines and legal exposure become harder to assess, otherwise attractive projects can be deferred or abandoned.

Accuracy also requires separating DRIPA from the Cowichan Aboriginal-title litigation. Constitutional Indigenous rights exist independently of this statute. Repeal would not erase them, nor automatically eliminate consultation requirements. The defensible criticism concerns legislative design, implementation and predictability, rather than the existence of Indigenous rights.

A better approach would combine clear statutory responsibilities, dependable decision deadlines, environmental safeguards and adequately funded consultation. Indigenous equity ownership and negotiated partnerships can support development while sharing its benefits. Reconciliation should make durable investment possible, with communities participating in prosperity.

Instead, British Columbia confronted weak growth alongside a projected $13.8-billion deficit for 2026–27. Borrowing can cushion shocks, but it cannot permanently replace competitive industries. From a capitalist perspective, expanding public commitments without sufficiently strengthening the businesses financing them creates a structural fiscal risk.

The economic case against Eby centres on stewardship: insufficient diversification beyond property, unresolved barriers to resource development and uncertainty over investment rules. Judged from a market-oriented perspective, these weaknesses undermine the NDP’s claim that greater government direction reliably produces broader, more sustainable prosperity.

Romel Dhalla, is President of Dhalla Advisory Corp., provides strategic corporate finance advice to companies and high net worth individuals. He was a portfolio manager and investment advisor with two major Canadian banks for 17 years. Contact him at romel@dacorp.ca. Any views or opinions represented in this article are personal and belong solely to the author and do not represent those of people, institutions or organizations that the author may or may not be associated with in professional or personal capacity, unless explicitly stated. Any views or opinions are not intended to malign any religion, ethnic group, club, organization, company, or individual.

To find out more about David Eby click here.

To go back to the main page click here.

Stay Updated

Get the latest news directly to your inbox.

Subscribe to Lifestyles 55

Get the magazine delivered directly to your inbox or doorstep. Support local journalism.